Welcome to the Monmouth County Pizzeria Smackdown. In the red corner, we have the one and only Italian restaurant in the town of Colts Neck, Orlando’s Italian Restaurant and Pizzeria!
The opponent in the blue corner hails from a modest shopping center in Freehold. Serving everything from cheesesteak to calzones, it’s Romeo’s Pizza and More! Let’s get ready to rumble.
I tried the plain cheese pizza from both restaurants. Orlando’s slice was $2, while Romeo’s pizza was $2.41.
Outside of the pizza itself, the service at both restaurants was great. The employees were kind and talkative towards every customer.
There was an obvious difference in the two slices: Romeo’s was much bigger. The slices in the pizzeria are much bigger than expected, and are only slightly more expensive than those at Orlando’s. I recommend ordering less slices than usual, because they are enormous portions.
Although both slices were delicious and would be excellent choices for anyone, they were extremely different. Romeo’s offered a crunchy crust and more seasoning, but was greasier than its opponent. Orlando’s was softer, but it became chewy at some points. Still, it had a good balance between the cheese, sauce and dough.
The pizza at Orlando’s would appeal to kids, especially picky eaters. It was hard to find any seasoning, and the crust was softer. The slice is also an appropriate portion for younger customers.
The Winner
Romeo’s takes the cake (or pizza?) in this match, but with such a worthy opponent, there were no losers. The huge slice packed a dynamic punch, leaving me wanting more.
Although Romeo’s is the winner for now, there are countless more pizzerias in Monmouth County. Be sure to recommend more Italian eateries if you want to see them featured here.
Ciao!